From the fan-favorite author of Underneath the Sycamore Tree comes the next installment in a raw, real romance series following the lives of the Lindon U football players and the complicated girls who change their lives forever. After Raine Copelin turns down her long-time boyfriend Caleb Anders's marriage proposal, the two are barely speaking, barely coping as they enter graduate school at Lindon University. Caleb doesn't understand--their relationship was picture-perfect, and he always imagined a family with her, one like the happily ever after his own parents found. They've been in love since high school. And yet when Raine broke his heart, she didn't even tell him why. But Raine has her reasons. Her secrets. She knows she can't give Caleb the future he wants, not without holding him back, so she decides she has to let him go.

But when fresh tragedy sends Caleb spiraling back into Raine's arms, the unanswered questions between them bring old feelings and wounds back to the surface. Fighting grief, loss, and fear, the pair must figure out if their love ever truly ended, and if their uncertain futures might still include each other's hearts.