"[T]he dramatic oil paintings have a striking impact, with varying perspectives and a theatrical sense of staging and lighting to increase the dramatic tension. Those who enjoyed the original story as well as cat-lovers of any age will savor the sweet flavor of Cookie's Christmas chronicle." Kirkus Reviews "[T]he illustrations really shine, with scenes and figures rendered in richly colored oils." Booklist "The artist's careful attention to light and shadow, along with the use of bold primary colors, gives the book a perfect blend of warmth and exuberance. This is a sweet, fun read-aloud for the cat-loving crowd." School Library Journal.