Preface Acknowledgments Abbreviations 1 Introduction Identifying the Problem The Moral and Epistemic Objection Prospectus 2 Warrant, Proper Function, and Christian Belief Proper Function and Design Plan An Objection to Externalism: Bonjour An Objection to Externalism: Bonjour on Armstrong A Proper Function Response to Bonjour's Counterexample Perception and Proper Function The Extended A/C Model and Proper Function 3 Epistemic Disagreement and the Equal Weight Theory Epistemic Disagreement: Kelly Two Additional Cases The Equal Weight Theory The Problem of Religious Diversity and the Equal Weight Theory 4 The Great Pumpkin Objection The Nature of Defeaters The Son of Great Pumpkin Objection: Martin and DeRose The Son of Great Pumpkin Objection: A Response 5 The Internalist Criterion and the Inadequacy Thesis Reformed Epistemology and the Internalist Criterion: Willard Reformed Epistemology and the Internalist Criterion: A Response The Inadequacy Thesis: Baker The Inadequacy Thesis: A Response Contents 6 The Central Issue of Religious Exclusivism Hick on the Central Issue of Religious Exclusivism Retrospection Bibliography Preface Acknowledgments Abbreviations 1 Introduction Identifying the Problem The Moral and Epistemic Objection Prospectus 2 Warrant, Proper Function, and Christian Belief Proper Function and Design Plan An Objection to Externalism: Bonjour An Objection to Externalism: Bonjour on Armstrong A Proper Function Response to Bonjour's Counterexample Perception and Proper Function The Extended A/C Model and Proper Function 3 Epistemic Disagreement and the Equal Weight Theory Epistemic Disagreement: Kelly Two Additional Cases The Equal Weight Theory The Problem of Religious Diversity and the Equal Weight Theory 4 The Great Pumpkin Objection The Nature of Defeaters The Son of Great Pumpkin Objection: Martin and DeRose The Son of Great Pumpkin Objection: A Response 5 The Internalist Criterion and the Inadequacy Thesis Reformed Epistemology and the Internalist Criterion: Willard Reformed Epistemology and the Internalist Criterion: A Response The Inadequacy Thesis: Baker The Inadequacy Thesis: A Response Contents 6 The Central Issue of Religious Exclusivism Hick on the Central Issue of Religious Exclusivism Retrospection Bibliography.