U. S. Peacetime Policy Toward Russia : Exploring the Benefits and Costs of a Less-Hardline Approach
U. S. Peacetime Policy Toward Russia : Exploring the Benefits and Costs of a Less-Hardline Approach
Click to enlarge
Author(s): Charap, Samuel
Frederick, Bryan
Priebe, Miranda
ISBN No.: 9781977410016
Pages: 222
Year: 202306
Format: Trade Paper
Price: $ 60.72
Dispatch delay: Dispatched between 7 to 15 days
Status: Available

Whenever and however Russias invasion of Ukraine ultimately ends, the U.S.-Russia relationship is likely to remain hostile in its aftermath. Over the long term, however, the United States will have incentives to reduce the risks and costs of its relationship with Russia in order to focus on other challenges, such as China. Future U.S. policymakers might therefore wish to again consider a limited less-hardline approach toward Russia. Supporters of such approaches contend that limited less-hardline approaches can reduce an adversarys insecurity, moderate its behavior, and reduce the costs and risks associated with competition between the two countries.


Critics are reluctant to make concessions to U.S. rivals and worry that softening the U.S. stance could embolden a rival to become more demanding and aggressive. The authors used four historical case studies of limited less-hardline approaches with strategic similarities to the U.S.-Russia relationship before the war in Ukraine to evaluate these competing claims.


These cases were (1) negotiations between Britain and Russia over Central Asia from 1899 to 1914 (2) U.S.-Soviet negotiations on the post-World War II order from 1945 to 1946, (3) the U.S.-Soviet détente from 1969 to 1975, and (4) the U.S.-Russia reset from 2009-2013. The authors found that such approaches have led to durable but narrow gains without emboldening the rival to be more demanding or aggressive.


These limited policies also have limited effects. They only reduce a rivals threat perceptions modestly and do not prevent future deterioration of the relationship over outstanding conflicts of interest.


To be able to view the table of contents for this publication then please subscribe by clicking the button below...
To be able to view the full description for this publication then please subscribe by clicking the button below...